Pass-through versus corporate taxation
Most small businesses are taxed as pass-throughs, where profit flows to the owners' personal returns. A C-corporation is taxed separately, and distributions to owners are taxed again. The second layer is why C-corp status suits businesses reinvesting rather than distributing.
The S-corporation self-employment angle
An S-corporation lets an owner-operator split income between salary and distribution, with self-employment tax applying only to the salary. The salary must be reasonable for the work performed; aggressive splits are a well-known audit focus.
What an S-corp costs you
- Payroll must be run, with its filings and deposits.
- A separate return is required.
- Ownership is restricted in ways that can block investment.
The savings only exceed the administrative cost above a certain profit level, which is the calculation worth doing before electing.
When C-corp makes sense
Businesses seeking institutional investment generally need to be C-corporations, because investor structures and certain stock benefits depend on it. Businesses retaining earnings for growth may also benefit.
Changing structure
Elections have deadlines and some changes have lasting consequences, including restrictions on changing back. This is worth deciding with advice rather than defaulting.
TallyWise provides this as part of our tax strategy services. Book a call to talk through your situation.